Should You Invest in a Hot Tub or Fire Pit?

When it comes to vacation rentals, small luxuries can make a big difference. Two of the most popular features guests love? Hot tubs and fire pits. Both add serious curb appeal—but which one is the better investment for your short-term rental?

Let’s break it down.

🔥 Fire Pit: Affordable Charm & Social Appeal

Pros:

• Budget-friendly: Fire pits are relatively inexpensive to install and maintain. Basic models start at around $150–$500.

• All-season use: Ideal for chilly evenings, s’mores, storytelling, and stargazing.

• Low maintenance: Just keep it clean and stocked with wood or propane.

• Photo-worthy: A cozy fire pit setup looks great in your listing photos.

Cons:

• Weather-dependent: Rain and wind can make it unusable.

• Local regulations: Some areas have burn bans or fire pit restrictions, especially in dry seasons.

Best for: Properties with outdoor space that want a low-cost upgrade with high guest satisfaction.

💦 Hot Tub: Luxury That Sells

Pros:

• High guest appeal: Hot tubs are one of the top search filters on Airbnb. They scream relaxation and luxury.

• Boosted booking rates: Listings with hot tubs often command higher nightly rates and fill up faster.

• Year-round use: Perfect in both winter and summer months, especially in mountain, rural, or romantic settings.

Cons:

• Upfront cost: Expect to spend $3,000–$8,000+ for purchase and installation.

• Ongoing maintenance: Requires regular cleaning, chemicals, and winterization in colder climates.

• Liability concerns: Safety rules and clear usage instructions are a must.

Best for: Hosts aiming for higher-end guests or targeting couples, ski travelers, or secluded getaways.

So… Which One Should You Choose?

Ask yourself:

• What’s your target audience? Families and groups may prefer a fire pit; couples and luxury seekers might want a hot tub.

• What’s your budget? Fire pits are more affordable, but hot tubs can pay off in the long run.

• Do you have time for maintenance? Fire pits require little upkeep, while hot tubs need regular care.

  
  

Final Verdict

Both a hot tub and a fire pit can elevate your guest experience and set your rental apart from the competition. If you’re just getting started or on a budget, a fire pit is an easy win. But if you’re ready to invest and want to stand out in search results, a hot tub could bring in bigger returns.